Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Rodeo: Cowgirls Compete With Men

Heidi M. Thomas, author
 Cowgirls Compete With Men
by Heidi M. Thomas
Copyright © 2012 Heidi M. Thomas

A petite young woman mounts a 750 to 900-pound steer, and hangs on to nothing but a rope tight-wrapped around one hand. That she stays on this bucking, twisting, snorting beast for ten seconds, eight seconds or even two seconds, seems a miracle.
This is the intriguing picture of my grandmother I have carried in the back of my mind since I was a little girl.
My grandmother, Olive May “Tootsie” Bailey, grew up the daughter of homesteaders during the early 1900s in the Sunburst-Cut Bank area of Montana, near the Canadian border and east of the Rocky Mountains.
Although she no longer rode in rodeos when I came along, “Gramma” was an avid horsewoman and ranch wife, equally at-home on the back of a horse as she was in a dress and heels. She and my grandfather, Otto Gasser, were partners in rural Montana ranching as well as an urban family of friends.
The 1920s were the heyday of rodeo, where the cowgirl was as much a part of the festivities as the cowboy. The first cowgirls learned to ride out of necessity to help on their family ranches. At an early age they learned to ride horses, rope cattle, and stay in the saddle atop an untamed bucking bronco.
In 1885, Annie Oakley, a diminutive sharpshooter in Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West Show, paved the way for other women to be recognized in the rodeo arena. Two years later, Bertha Kaelpernick was allowed to enter a horse race in Cheyenne’s Frontier Days only because the arena was so muddy the cowboys refused to participate. To entertain the crowd, she was coerced into riding a bucking horse.
Despite the terrible conditions, she managed to stay in the saddle, and put the men to shame. She continued to compete and often beat such legendary cowboys as Ben Corbett and Hoot Gibson.
Following in Bertha’s footsteps years later, Prairie Rose Henderson of Wyoming forced the Cheyenne organizers to allow her to ride. She went on to become one of the most flamboyant cowgirls of the era, dressing in bright colors, sequins and ostrich plumes over bloomers.
Lucille Mulhall, whose father, Colonel Zack Mulhall, ran a Wild West Show, was described in a 1900 New York World article as “only ninety pounds, can break a bronc, lasso and brand a steer, and shoot a coyote at 500 yards. She can also play Chopin, quote Browning, and make mayonnaise.” Both Teddy Roosevelt and Will Rogers have been credited with giving Lucille the title “cowgirl.”
Between 1885 and 1935, many women proudly wore that title and competed with men, riding broncs, steers and bulls. They also roped and tied steers (usually wearing long divided skirts) alongside their male counterparts.
In early rodeos, women and men competed in the same arena, drawing from the same stock. Women rode broncs, steers, bulls, and did steer roping as well as trick riding, Roman races and relay races.
I know that my grandmother, Toots Bailey Gasser, rode steers in small Montana rodeos. Other cowgirls, such as Marie Gibson, also from Montana, rode steers, bulls and broncs throughout the US, Canada and even London. While each cowgirl had her specialty, most participated in multiple events.
Vera McGinnis, Tad Lucas and Fox Hastings were probably best known for trick riding. This demonstrated numerous types of stands and vaults, performed while the horse was galloping at top speed. Other maneuvers included crawling under the horse’s belly, hanging just inches from the mount’s pounding hooves.
In the Roman race, the cowgirl would stand with her right foot on one galloping horse and her left foot on the other. (The horses would have had to be very well trained to stay together, and the rider obviously had great balance and strength.)
The relay race required three laps around a track, and the rider had to change horses, and sometimes saddles, after each round. If they weren’t required to change saddles, many cowgirls perfected the “flying” change, leaping from the back of one horse to the other without touching the ground. Vera McGinnis is credited with inventing this move. 

Bonnie McCarrol
thrown from Silver, 1915

After Bonnie McCarrol and Marie Gibson were killed and several other women badly injured in rodeo accidents, cowgirl bronc riding became increasingly rare in the West, leaving only relay racing open to women competitors. But women’s rodeo gradually eroded nationwide for several reasons:
  • Small, local rodeos were no longer financially lucrative and livestock was in short supply in the 1930s, leading to the demise of the Wild West shows.
  • Men held the central control of the sport.
  • Many well-known women rodeo stars retired.
  • World War II, with tire and gas rationing, did not allow travel as in the past.
From the mid-1930s until the late 1940s, cowgirls became mere props in rodeo, “glamour girls” whose beauty and attire were emphasized instead of athletic skill. In 1948, 38 women formed the Girls Rodeo Association (GRA) to give women an opportunity to compete in calf roping, barrel racing, and trick riding. In 1968, barrel racing finals were finally included in the men’s Professional Rodeo Cowboys Association (PRCA) National Finals.
In 1981 GRA changed its name to Women’s Professional Rodeo Association (WPRA) and today has more than 2,000 members. It sanctions 800 barrel races a year in conjunction with men’s PRCA rodeos. But women still do not compete with men.

As an entity of its own, Professional Women’s Rodeo Association (PWRA) puts on events in women-only rodeos that include bareback riding, breakaway and tie-down calf roping, bull riding, and team roping.
It’s been a long time coming, but as Rene Mikes, a corporate accountant from Denver and a bull rider, says, “It’s not a guy sport anymore.” But despite the heroic efforts of many women, including Cowgirl Hall of Fame and world champion bull rider Joni Jonkowski of Montana, women for the most part still do not compete with men.
Since the formation of the RAA in 1929, only one woman has qualified, within the PRCA’s point system, to compete in saddle bronc riding with men. That woman is Kaila Mussell from BC, Canada. She has been nominated to the Cowgirls Hall of Fame.
Heidi offers autographed copies at her website, or you can purchase Follow the Dream at these online stores: Amazon ~ Barnes & Noble ~ Treble Heart Books

Enter To Win
Your Choice Of
Heidi's Books!

Please leave a comment about a favorite western novel or a favorite strong character and you’ll be entered into a drawing for an autographed copy of your choice of Follow the Dream or Cowgirl Dreams.  The winning comment will be drawn 10pm Pacific Time, Saturday, January 28th.  Don't forget to include your email address with your comment or another name will be drawn.

Enter win a Free Kindle and Six Free Books!


  1. My husband and I visited Montana from Scotland in 2008 and loved it. Unfortunately we weren't able to catch a rodeo but hope to get back one day and see one. We met a lassie who told us about her friend who was a rodeo rider - until then we had no idea women even did this!
    Not a novel but I bought John Taliaferro's biography of Charles M Russell, whose work we greatly admired when we visited Great Falls.
    I enjoyed this blog post a lot - thank you.
    Janet O'Kane (jokwriting [at] btinternet [dot] com

  2. Heidi, how exciting it must have been for your grandmother to perform in rodeos. My neighbor did trick riding in a Wild West Show in Fort Worth for several years. By the way, I'm related to a bunch of Baileys way back. I'd love to think you're one of them.

  3. HEIDI--just when I think I know everything about Texas and the West, I learn I do not. I never knew females competed with the men in rodeos. It's a fascinating concept, and once again, makes me realize how much history there is in the Old West. And isn't it a shame that such events as a war or gas rationing brought a stop to all these wonderful spectacles.
    I thoroughly enjoyed reading your post...thanks.

  4. Heidi, I forgot to tell you my favorite western novel and character. One of my all-time favorites IS MUCH ADO ABOUT MARSHALLS by Jacquie Rogers. Another is Louis L'Amour's FALLON, and Fallon is probably my favorite character because he is a man who feels he is worthless, yet who has remarkable gifts to offer.

  5. Janet, I'm so glad you enjoyed your visit to Montana. Russell was a great western artist!

    Caroline, wouldn't that be fun if we were related somehow?!

    Celia, yes the old west certainly does hold a lot of history the general public doesn't know about.

  6. Heidi, I love these stories of early women in rodeos. I do hpe that your proposal for a non-fiction work is accepted. I think the reading public will be very interested.

  7. Heidi, I love these stories of early women in rodeos. I do hpe that your proposal for a non-fiction work is accepted. I think the reading public will be very interested.

  8. As a young boy in my far-away native country, I was thrilled by accounts of the Old West that I read in pulp magazines we boys passed from one to the other. We all dreamt and romanticized about the Old West. And now I am here, having seen it first-hand and having read about it in Heidi's excellent novels. What an incredible adventure! Thanks Heidi for opening new horizons for me and no doubt, many others.

  9. Heidi, With the 100th anniversary of the Pendleton Stampede in 2011 there have been several programs on OPB about the women who rode bucking broncs at heir competitions. What a wonderful heritage to have in your background.

  10. Heidi, Your grandmother would be proud of your western remembrances of her, and your continued success! It's about time early rodeo women were given the credit due them.


Romancing The West welcomes you to show your appreciation of our guest blogger by leaving a comment. If there's a contest, don't forget to leave your contact information. Thanks!